# When the Diagnosis Becomes the Harm

Blog 

By Guest Blog

12th November 2026

***With thanks to Cherelle Mead, our Wales Regional Representative, for this article.***

I recently sat in a room in Wales with professionals, people with lived experience and organisations from across mental health and the third sector, brought together by Platfform to discuss its most recent campaign around the hidden harm associated with the diagnosis of personality disorder.

I went into the room as Wales Representative for the National Counselling and Psychotherapy Society, but inevitably I brought much more than my professional title with me. I came as a psychotherapist who has spent years sitting alongside people whose distress often makes considerably more sense when we become curious about what has happened to them. I also came with my interest in anti-oppressive practice and the questions this continually asks us about whose stories are believed and whose are more easily dismissed, alongside my own experiences of being a woman trying to be heard within healthcare.

This subject feels personal to me for another reason too. When I think about the women I have known throughout my life, I struggle to think of many who do not have a story of dismissal, disbelief or injustice somewhere within their experience of health or wellbeing. The feeling of having to convince somebody that your pain, distress or knowledge of your own body is real is sadly familiar to many.

Perhaps that is why one question kept returning to me throughout the discussion: **what happens when a system becomes more certain about its interpretation of a person than curious about the person themselves?**

Platfform’s *Hidden Harm of the Diagnosis of Personality Disorder* report grew from its Truth Project, which centres first-person accounts of people’s experiences within the mental-health system. The report draws on the experiences of 30 people who had received a personality-disorder diagnosis. Their stories make difficult reading. People describe trauma being overlooked, physical and emotional distress being dismissed, and later encounters with professionals being shaped by a diagnosis that seemed to enter the room before they did.

Platfform’s campaign asks us to take seriously the possibility that, rather than opening a door to support, this particular diagnosis can become a barrier to it. This is not simply a theoretical debate about diagnostic language. It is a conversation about what happens to real people after a label enters their medical records and begins to shape how their distress is understood.

This feels particularly important when we consider gender. Platfform reports that women account for around 75% of people given a personality-disorder diagnosis within mental-health services. That disparity asks us to consider not simply who experiences these symptoms of distress, but how distress is interpreted when somebody reaches a service.

A psychiatric diagnosis such as borderline personality disorder, or BPD, is not established through a blood test, scan or genetic marker. It comes from interpreting patterns in somebody’s emotions, relationships, sense of self and behaviour against a set of diagnostic criteria. Those experiences are real and can be profoundly painful, but the meaning we give them cannot be completely separated from the culture in which we are making that judgement.

During the roundtable, we wondered how gender influences what we as health professionals see. How do we understand anger when it comes from a woman, for example, or emotional intensity, distrust, changing relationships or a desperate need to feel safe? How might we understand those same behaviours differently if we knew more about the person’s history, the relationships they have survived and the social conditions surrounding them?

Those questions become even more important when we think intersectionally. A woman may also be racialised, queer, neurodivergent, disabled, living in poverty or a survivor of violence. These experiences do not sit neatly beside one another. They shape how somebody moves through the world, but they may also shape how the world responds to them. It leaves me wondering whose stories are missing altogether because some people have had even fewer opportunities to be heard.

Trauma is difficult to ignore within this conversation. Research has repeatedly found very high levels of childhood adversity among people diagnosed with BPD, with some studies reporting histories of abuse or neglect in more than 80% of participants. This does not mean trauma explains every person’s experience, and replacing one rigid explanation with another would not move us forward. It does, however, make it difficult to understand why curiosity about what somebody has lived through would ever be considered optional. There is something deeply uncomfortable about taking ways of coping that may have developed in response to trauma and locating the problem entirely inside the person who learned to cope that way.

One of the most affecting parts of the roundtable was hearing the testimony of Jess Matthews, one of the women who shared her lived experience through Platfform’s work. Jess described a diagnosis that became much more than a description of her distress. It began to determine how her emotions, choices and requests for support were interpreted by others.

Her experience opened up a wider discussion about what can happen after a BPD diagnosis has been made. Somebody trying to find support may begin carefully managing how they present themselves to professionals because they have learned that being perceived in the “wrong” way can affect whether they are believed. They might change their tone, monitor their body language or try to communicate differently with different professionals in an attempt to be heard. Yet once somebody is already viewed through a particular diagnostic lens, those adaptations can themselves be interpreted as further evidence of pathology, perhaps as inconsistency, manipulation or “splitting”. The person can become caught in a loop where their response to not being believed becomes another reason not to believe them. For somebody whose original trauma was relational, particularly where those relationships involved power, this has the potential to repeat something painfully familiar. Once again, somebody with greater authority gets to decide what their experience means.

Platfform’s Truth Project contains many accounts that bring this to life, and I would encourage NCPS members to read some of those stories for themselves. They describe lost agency, stigma and changes in how people were treated once a diagnosis appeared in their records. They remind us that behind conversations about diagnostic frameworks are individual people trying to have their experiences understood. This complexity matters. The wider question is not whether diagnosis can *ever* help. Finding language for an experience can bring relief, validation and access to support for some people. The question is what happens when that language stops being one possible tool for understanding somebody and becomes the main lens through which everything about them is understood, shutting down enquiry and becoming the end of curiosity before that curiosity has even begun.

I have seen this repeatedly over the years in my own private practice. Clients sometimes arrive with a stream of diagnoses that mean very little to them, having moved through services without anybody asking some of the questions that might begin the work of making sense of their experiences. As counsellors and psychotherapists, this is something many NCPS members may recognise. We know how much the meaning of behaviour can change when we understand its context. Asking *what is wrong with you?* takes us somewhere very different from wondering what has happened around somebody, what they have had to learn in order to survive it, and what their responses might be communicating now.

During the roundtable we were also shown a trailer for *Traumality*, a new independent documentary created by filmmaker Ton Mazzone. The film brings together lived experience with voices from trauma, psychotherapy and psychology including Peter Levine, Janina Fisher, Richard Schwartz, Deb Dana and Jessica Taylor. It looks beyond personality disorder specifically to question the wider dominance of a symptom-focused medical model of mental health, asking what changes when we understand distress through trauma, relationships and lived experience rather than beginning and ending with diagnosis.

Watching the trailer brought us back to a wider tension that runs through much of this conversation: the difference between medical and social ways of understanding human difficulty. The social model emerged from the disability-rights movement as a challenge to the idea that the problem sits entirely within an individual. Rather than denying that bodies, minds, illness or impairment can cause real difficulty, it asks us also to notice the barriers around a person and the ways that environments, attitudes and systems can increase or even create disability. Wales formally adopted the Social Model of Disability in 2002, and it continues to influence Welsh policy today.

I wonder what happens when we bring some of that thinking into our understanding of emotional distress. This does not require us to reject medicine or diagnosis altogether, or to deny that people sometimes need and benefit enormously from medical intervention. It asks something more subtle: whether locating distress primarily within an individual can sometimes stop us noticing what is happening around them. Trauma, poverty, discrimination, violence, insecure housing, racism, misogyny, ableism and exclusion do not disappear simply because somebody meets diagnostic criteria.

Sometimes I wonder whether what services describe as increasingly “complex” people are actually people carrying the accumulated effects of complex systems. Mental-health services are stretched and third-sector organisations are often left trying to hold people who have repeatedly fallen through gaps in the services intended to support them. By the time somebody reaches a small community organisation or an individual therapist, they may be carrying not only their original trauma but the experiences they have accumulated while trying to get help for it. This cannot be completely separated from scarcity, funding and the wider structures surrounding healthcare. There are also legitimate conversations to be had about the relationship between psychiatric knowledge and the pharmaceutical industry. Research published in *The BMJ*, for example, has identified substantial financial links to industry among US physician members involved in DSM-5-TR panels and its task force. This does not mean psychiatric diagnoses can simply be dismissed, but it does remind us that professional knowledge is created within systems too, and those systems deserve some of the same curiosity we ask professionals to bring to the people they support.

This is where I find the Welsh context particularly hopeful. Health is devolved in Wales, which gives us opportunities to think about the kind of mental-health culture we want to create here. Some of the thinking we need is already present within Welsh policy. *Ask and Act* recognises connections between health, violence and abuse, while the NEST framework’s “No Wrong Door” approach for children, young people and families recognises what can happen when people are passed between disconnected services. Wales’s Reducing Restrictive Practices Framework approaches restrictions on people’s freedom through a human-rights lens and recognises that restrictive interventions can themselves cause trauma or retraumatisation.

There is important work happening around women’s health too. Fair Treatment for the Women of Wales brought something particularly valuable to the roundtable through its peer-led campaigning around health inequalities and the importance of women being involved in shaping the services that affect them. For me, this is also where the NCPS Wales Representative role has real meaning. The Society describes its regional representatives as its “eyes and ears on the ground”, helping it understand the political, social and professional landscape affecting practitioners and their clients in different parts of the UK. Being able to sit at this table, and at others like it across Wales, means counselling and psychotherapy are part of conversations that extend beyond the therapy room. It also means I can bring what I hear from NCPS members into those spaces and bring these wider conversations back to our membership.I think that matters. Counsellors and psychotherapists often meet people after they have already travelled through many of the systems being discussed. We hear stories that do not always fit neatly into service pathways or diagnostic categories, and we have an opportunity to contribute a relational perspective while listening carefully to what people with lived experience are telling us.

That does not mean our profession stands outside structures of power. We interpret people too. We formulate, decide what we believe is happening and inevitably bring our own cultural understanding into the therapeutic relationship. Anti-oppressive practice asks us to notice that power rather than imagine that being caring or well-intentioned makes us neutral. Perhaps part of our contribution can be maintaining curiosity when systems have become certain, helping people reconnect with the meaning of their own stories when those stories have been reduced to symptoms, while remaining willing to question our own interpretations too. This feels closely connected to the NCPS commitment to ensuring that people feel seen, valued and heard, and to recognising the ways institutional discrimination and oppression can shape people's lives. Having representation within conversations such as this gives us an opportunity not only to advocate for our profession, but to listen to the communities our profession exists to serve.

One of the things I found most hopeful about the roundtable was the room itself. Professionals, campaigners, third-sector organisations and people bringing lived experience were talking across boundaries that so often separate our work. There was already considerable shared knowledge about where harm is occurring, but the conversation was moving towards what might actually be different. In a small devolved nation, there is something exciting about that possibility.

It left us wondering whether Wales could go further in thinking about consent around highly stigmatising diagnoses and how they are recorded, whether people could have more meaningful ways of questioning a formulation they believe is harming them, and what access to another professional opinion really means when somebody may have only one local team available. I also wonder whether the work already happening around women's voices in physical healthcare might help us think differently about how we listen to women within mental-health services.

I don't think we need simple answers to these questions. Perhaps part of the difficulty has been our desire to find simple explanations for complicated human experiences. What I came away with instead was a renewed belief in the importance of context and curiosity, and in creating systems where professional knowledge can sit alongside lived experience rather than automatically above it. For me, there is real value in the NCPS having a place within these conversations in Wales, particularly as we continue thinking about what trauma-informed and anti-oppressive practice looks like not only inside our therapy rooms, but in the wider systems our clients have to navigate.

If we want services that are genuinely trauma-informed, we have to be willing to look not only at the person experiencing distress, but at the relationships, cultures and structures surrounding them.

Sometimes the most important question may not be whether we have found the right label for somebody. It may be whether we have heard enough of their story to understand what we are trying to name.

### Further reading

Platfform's *Truth Project* shares first-person accounts from people who have experienced the mental-health system, including stories relating to the diagnosis of personality disorder.

Platfform's *The Hidden Harm of the Diagnosis of Personality Disorder* report sets out the findings and recommendations that formed the basis of the roundtable discussed here.

*Traumality*, written and directed by Ton Mazzone, explores trauma, adversity and the medical model through expert and lived-experience perspectives.