NCPS response to the Milburn review: a welcome move towards needs-led support for young people

Alan Milburn's final Young People and Work review, From a Welfare State to a Working State, was published yesterday, and we were heartened to see counselling recognised as part of the answer to one of the most pressing challenges facing young people, and the country.
Almost a million young people aren't in education, employment or training (NEET). It’s a huge number, and worth remembering that every single one of those is a young person who is struggling. The difficulties behind the numbers are built over years, often while young people wait for help that comes too late, or not at all, which is why the review's call to move away from the 'diagnose, wait, treat' model is so important.
It is often argued that young people lack resilience, and that we are dealing with a generation more inclined to apathy than those before it. This is factually incorrect; the Milburn and Fonagy reviews emphatically reject this perspective. More than seven in ten NEETs want to be in work, education, or training; they do not lack the drive, they lack the opportunities and an effective model of support.
The Society has long called for support based on need, rather than requiring a formal diagnosis or the meeting of a referral threshold, and we’re pleased to see the recommendation that young people who are NEET should get fast-track access to counselling and other talking therapies through the proposed Youth Opportunity Service. We’re also glad to see the explicit recognition of brief, in-person counselling for young people who need it.
The review proposes a digital-first front door, and while many argue that young people being able to get advice and support straight away is of utmost importance, it remains to be seen how that digital offer will impact on the relational, face-to-face support so many young people need, and that, realistically, if they want digital support they can easily get it elsewhere.
Our joint research with Barnardo's, surveying 2,000 children and young people aged 11 - 17, found that 43% had already used AI for advice or emotional support, yet only 4% would turn to a chatbot first if they needed help. Young people are using what's available, not necessarily what they'd choose, so we'll be advocating to make sure that in-person options remain available and meaningful. Young people's autonomy over how, where, and with whom they get support is a big part of whether that support works.
The workforce to deliver the support that the report calls for already exists: counsellors & psychotherapists on PSA Accredited Registers are trained, accountable and available. NHS England's recent inclusion of counsellors & psychotherapists in its psychological professions taxonomy makes it easier than ever for commissioners to draw on them. What's needed now are commissioning routes that let young people reach that support.
We also share the view of our colleagues at Future Minds that the Government's response to Milburn and the forthcoming Mental Health Strategy should work as two stages of one plan. Much of what young people at risk of becoming NEET need isn't clinical at all: it's drop-in, community-based support in places they already are, through Early Support Hubs and Mental Health Support Teams that properly reach further education colleges (where coverage is at just 29% of post-16 settings, versus 78% of secondary schools).
We’re also supportive of the the Psychotherapy and Counselling Union (PCU), whose response rightly makes the point that school counselling is an essential but too often overlooked part of preventing young people becoming NEET. The review itself recognises that schools know early who's likely to struggle, and school counsellors are already working with emotionally based school avoidance, distress, and disengagement long before a young person leaves education. We share PCU's call for school counselling to be recognised as a distinct part of the education workforce, named explicitly in strategies on mental health, attendance, safeguarding, SEND and inclusion, and backed by stable funding and workforce planning that lets schools directly recruit and keep qualified counsellors & psychotherapists.
Meg Moss, Head of Public Affairs & Advocacy at the NCPS said:
"It's so very encouraging to see counselling recognised in the Milburn review, and to see such a clear commitment to supporting young people based on what they need, rather than whether they've got a diagnosis or meet a threshold.
Young people want to be heard by someone they trust, in a setting that feels right to them. There's a skilled, regulated workforce of counsellors & psychotherapists ready to help, and the ambition in this review now needs matching with sustainable funding and commissioning that lets young people reach that support quickly".
We'll be engaging with Government as it develops its response, and we'll keep members updated on what this means for practice, and on opportunities to get involved.



